Part VIII: Complaints, Decisions, and Appeals
Procedure should clarify facts, not drag people into endless statements of self-criticism. Serious risks may be blocked first; misunderstandings must still have room for explanation. Penalties must correspond to conduct, appeals need an outlet, and spectators should remember they are not themselves evidence.
Chapter 71: Where to Make a Complaint
The appeal desk does not sell spectator snacks
Article 731: Scope of Freedom
Reporting specific problems privately or through a designated method is part of normal participation. Rules should leave room for this participation rather than turn casual conversation into an exam that only a few established friends can enter. Members need not make every remark conclusive or get a like for every contribution. A remark no one picks up is still permitted.
Article 732: Voluntary Participation
Members decide for themselves how much to participate in Where to Make a Complaint. Every invitation should permit refusal, and every request should permit a later reply. Silence is neither a promise nor a confession others may interpret however they like. Willingness to participate today does not require the same level of involvement tomorrow.
Article 733: Clear Boundaries
This chapter restricts specific overreach, such as turning a complaint into public humiliation and organizing attacks. This restriction must not become a ban on the entire topic. Nor does past popularity make an expression suitable for everyone forever. Describe the conduct before discussing whether action is needed. Popularity, familiarity, and administrative status do not replace boundaries.
Article 734: Hypothetical Example
Consider this hypothetical example: a complainant immediately starts a group-wide trial and demands that everyone take sides. Even an ordinary conversation can develop beyond the scope of the original consent. Assess what actually happened, whether its effects continue, and whether it can be stopped promptly. Saying 'We all knew each other well' must not deprive affected people of a voice.
Article 735: Recommended Response
First collect necessary material and move the handling to a suitable, quiet channel. Protection and repair take priority over getting the last word. Problems resolved by stopping, withdrawing, and clarifying need not become demands for the whole group to take sides. Where the actual conduct constitutes fraud, unlawful activity, or malicious harassment, this constitution's immediate blocking and direct removal provisions apply.
Article 736: Context and Explanation
In discussions of Where to Make a Complaint, brief messages may lack tone, screenshots may omit earlier context, and accounts from others may introduce inaccuracies. Good-faith questions can clarify a problem, but no one must endlessly prove they meant no harm. Where a clear boundary remains after necessary context is explained, acknowledge it and stop crossing it.
Article 737: Information and Privacy
Keep only the parts of material concerning Where to Make a Complaint that are genuinely relevant to the present issue. Conceal nicknames, faces, numbers, locations, and unrelated third-party information wherever that does not prevent explaining the facts. Providing material to address a problem does not authorize members to keep sharing it, turn it into a spectacle, or make new memes from it. Recipients must respect the same boundaries.
Article 738: Administrative Duties
In matters of Where to Make a Complaint, administrators are first ordinary members with limited responsibilities. Those handling the issue should distinguish ordinary chat opinions from administrative decisions, give clear reasons for necessary measures, and avoid collecting information beyond the issue's scope. More available authority requires greater care in explaining its purpose. Using authority to threaten, show favoritism, or disclose private information must be subject to scrutiny.
Article 739: Statements and Appeals
Parties involved in Where to Make a Complaint may explain their understanding, add necessary records, and request review. Not continuing an argument after a warning prevents further effects; it does not remove the right to explain. Order cannot be maintained by banning every disagreement. Uninvolved spectators should not speak on behalf of the parties. Reviews should address specific facts and applicable boundaries.
Article 740: Repair and Restoration
Handling Where to Make a Complaint must not end with merely telling everyone to move along. Complete any necessary withdrawal, explanation, or adjustment for effects that can be corrected, then tell those involved the current status. Correct wrongful penalties and stop the circulation of false information. Future interaction should respect present boundaries; nobody must pretend every relationship is restored, and past events must not be used for continued attacks.
Chapter 72: Complaint Details and Acceptance
A complaint needs no certificate of perfect character
Article 741: Scope of Freedom
Explain what happened, when it happened, and what you want stopped. As long as no clear boundary is crossed, this requires neither prior permission nor proof of some grand value to the whole group. Members may participate seriously or simply nod in passing. Obscurity, ordinariness, childishness, and spontaneous thoughts are no grounds for taking away someone's right to chat.
Article 742: Voluntary Participation
Participation in matters covered by this chapter is voluntary. When discussing Complaint Details and Acceptance, do not pressure someone through group teasing, repeated persuasion, or bargaining with the closeness of a relationship into agreeing to something they do not want. You may ask once whether it is convenient, but stop when you hear a refusal. Do not supply consent on another person's behalf where they have not clearly agreed.
Article 743: Clear Boundaries
This chapter expressly opposes demanding proof of a complainant's character unrelated to the incident. Members need not present themselves as unusually strong or fragile before setting a boundary. Others may refuse and ask an action to stop. The person acting should first stop causing further effects, then explain any misunderstanding they believe exists; argument must not delay stopping.
Article 744: Hypothetical Example
For example: someone reporting harassment is pressed to explain why they previously wanted to chat. This situation illustrates a boundary and does not refer to any event that has already occurred in this group. Examine the original topic, subsequent additional conduct, and whether the other person expressed refusal separately. Do not overlook the affected person because everyone laughed, or treat the number of spectators as proof of the facts.
Article 745: Recommended Response
Return to the present behavior and boundary instead of judging the affected person's life. This is a response to particular behavior, not a formula to apply mechanically without considering the facts. Ordinary misunderstandings can be clarified; clear harm must stop. Ongoing fraud, unlawful acts, or malicious harassment should be blocked immediately and the person removed. Later explanations need not delay protection of members.
Article 746: Context and Explanation
Understand Complaint Details and Acceptance in this chapter in context. Exaggerated fictional scenarios, quoted text, and words addressed directly to a person may serve different purposes. Simply saying 'It's a meme' cannot end the assessment. Explain the actual meaning and original intention as clearly as possible. If the other person still does not want to receive that expression, both sides may end the related interaction.
Article 747: Information and Privacy
When explaining Complaint Details and Acceptance, prioritize anonymity, summaries, and only the minimum necessary information. A problem that can be explained by describing behavior does not require full identities and every private record. Material retains privacy boundaries even within an administrative process. A complaint about someone does not make everything about that person available for unrestricted disclosure.
Article 748: Administrative Duties
When handling an issue involving Complaint Details and Acceptance, administrators should explain the specific conduct and applicable boundaries, taking necessary measures based on its actual effects. Administrative status neither turns personal preferences into rules nor grants unlimited power to demand information. Disputes directly involving an administrator should be reviewed by someone without a direct conflict of interest. Resting or being offline is not, in itself, a failure of duty.
Article 749: Statements and Appeals
This chapter keeps a route open for explanations and appeals concerning Complaint Details and Acceptance. Members may acknowledge mistakes or point out facts omitted from a decision. Politely doing the latter must not be punished as 'talking back.' Restrictions addressing a clear, urgent risk may be applied before review. If the grounds are insufficient or the judgment wrong, make an actual correction rather than merely say 'Be more careful next time.'
Article 750: Repair and Restoration
Once the problem involving Complaint Details and Acceptance has stopped, consider how to restore ordinary conversation and the parties' normal participation. Apologies should address specific behavior and its effects. Material that needs withdrawing should actually be withdrawn, with further circulation stopped as far as possible. Do not force affected people to accept an apology, or keep humiliating someone with past events after they have corrected their conduct and the matter is closed.
Chapter 73: Evidence and Context
Evidence needs its before and after
Article 751: Scope of Freedom
This chapter recognizes the freedom to submit necessary chat records that explain a problem. Members need not perform humor, produce achievements, or satisfy anyone's aesthetic preferences to gain permission. A topic may begin with an ordinary remark and end naturally. Popularity does not determine whether expression deserves respect. Anyone uninterested may simply skip it.
Article 752: Voluntary Participation
When it comes to Evidence and Context, members may choose to watch, respond briefly, discuss seriously, or step away temporarily. None of these choices requires evidence about a person's private life. Past enthusiasm is not an obligation to remain enthusiastic now. A change in expression does not automatically mean someone is targeting a person or disrespecting the group.
Article 753: Clear Boundaries
Do not fabricate through editing, convict through speculation, or expose unrelated private information. Assess boundaries through specific behavior, context at the time, and the wishes the other person has expressed—not merely the actor's claim about their own intentions. Jokes may be appreciated or refused. Once refusal is clear, continuing cannot be resolved simply by explaining a sense of humor.
Article 754: Hypothetical Example
Imagine this situation: a screenshot retains only a reply while deleting the insults that preceded it. Address the specific new harm rather than every member participating in the topic. Stop the action currently causing effects first, then calmly check its context. Those who did not participate in the harm should not be made to confess collectively or automatically treated as guilty for watching.
Article 755: Recommended Response
Check the necessary context and conceal information about unrelated people. Every step should help stop the actual problem, without unrelated punishment or rituals of humiliation. Use necessary, proportionate measures in ordinary cases. Clear fraud, unlawful conduct, or malicious harassment may lead directly to removal; harm need not continue merely to reach a required warning count.
Article 756: Context and Explanation
When disagreeing about Evidence and Context, first distinguish the original words, assumptions, and your own feelings. You may say 'This is how I understand it' or 'This makes me uncomfortable.' Unchecked assumptions must not be packaged as facts 'everyone knows.' Clarification does not require immediate forgiveness, nor does it release the actor from stopping ongoing effects.
Article 757: Information and Privacy
When sharing or checking records concerning Evidence and Context, explain their purpose clearly and limit their circulation. Possessing a screenshot does not authorize unrestricted sharing. Information that has appeared in the group does not automatically become public property. Clear unrelated copies after the matter is resolved. Necessary retained records should be available only to people with actual responsibility for handling the issue, and only for that purpose.
Article 758: Administrative Duties
Administrative measures concerning Evidence and Context should restore normal participation, rather than prove that an administrator has won. When a reminder is needed, specify the behavior. When a risk needs removing, act promptly. Matters involving oneself, close associates, or personal grudges require appropriate recusal. Administrators need not be online all day, but must not use their status to retaliate against reasonable questions.
Article 759: Statements and Appeals
If a decision concerning Evidence and Context involves a misunderstanding, relevant explanations may be supplied privately, and polite questions raised about the facts, rules, and proportionality. First stop the boundary-crossing conduct you have been asked to stop, then explain the necessary context. This does not require admitting an allegation that has not been established. An administrator must not impose an additional punishment merely because someone appeals.
Article 760: Repair and Restoration
Repair under this chapter may include clarifying the facts concerning Evidence and Context, deleting content that should not be circulated, ending contact, or adjusting relevant arrangements. Repair is neither a performance of self-criticism nor a demand that both sides become close again. Affected people may keep their distance. A person who has completed the appropriate response must not be labeled indefinitely. Assess new problems through new, specific conduct.
Chapter 74: Statements From the Person Complained About
The right to explain is no license to chase people
Article 761: Scope of Freedom
Learning the necessary allegations and offering relevant explanations are part of normal participation. Rules should leave room for this participation rather than turn casual conversation into an exam that only a few established friends can enter. Members need not make every remark conclusive or get a like for every contribution. A remark no one picks up is still permitted.
Article 762: Voluntary Participation
Members decide for themselves how much to participate in Statements From the Person Complained About. Every invitation should permit refusal, and every request should permit a later reply. Silence is neither a promise nor a confession others may interpret however they like. Willingness to participate today does not require the same level of involvement tomorrow.
Article 763: Clear Boundaries
This chapter restricts specific overreach, such as continuing to harass a party during the time allowed for a statement. This restriction must not become a ban on the entire topic. Nor does past popularity make an expression suitable for everyone forever. Describe the conduct before discussing whether action is needed. Popularity, familiarity, and administrative status do not replace boundaries.
Article 764: Hypothetical Example
Consider this hypothetical example: the subject of a complaint keeps privately contacting the complainant in the name of confrontation. Even an ordinary conversation can develop beyond the scope of the original consent. Assess what actually happened, whether its effects continue, and whether it can be stopped promptly. Saying 'We all knew each other well' must not deprive affected people of a voice.
Article 765: Recommended Response
First stop direct contact and have the person handling the matter relay necessary questions. Protection and repair take priority over getting the last word. Problems resolved by stopping, withdrawing, and clarifying need not become demands for the whole group to take sides. Where the actual conduct constitutes fraud, unlawful activity, or malicious harassment, this constitution's immediate blocking and direct removal provisions apply.
Article 766: Context and Explanation
In discussions of Statements From the Person Complained About, brief messages may lack tone, screenshots may omit earlier context, and accounts from others may introduce inaccuracies. Good-faith questions can clarify a problem, but no one must endlessly prove they meant no harm. Where a clear boundary remains after necessary context is explained, acknowledge it and stop crossing it.
Article 767: Information and Privacy
Keep only the parts of material concerning Statements From the Person Complained About that are genuinely relevant to the present issue. Conceal nicknames, faces, numbers, locations, and unrelated third-party information wherever that does not prevent explaining the facts. Providing material to address a problem does not authorize members to keep sharing it, turn it into a spectacle, or make new memes from it. Recipients must respect the same boundaries.
Article 768: Administrative Duties
In matters of Statements From the Person Complained About, administrators are first ordinary members with limited responsibilities. Those handling the issue should distinguish ordinary chat opinions from administrative decisions, give clear reasons for necessary measures, and avoid collecting information beyond the issue's scope. More available authority requires greater care in explaining its purpose. Using authority to threaten, show favoritism, or disclose private information must be subject to scrutiny.
Article 769: Statements and Appeals
Parties involved in Statements From the Person Complained About may explain their understanding, add necessary records, and request review. Not continuing an argument after a warning prevents further effects; it does not remove the right to explain. Order cannot be maintained by banning every disagreement. Uninvolved spectators should not speak on behalf of the parties. Reviews should address specific facts and applicable boundaries.
Article 770: Repair and Restoration
Handling Statements From the Person Complained About must not end with merely telling everyone to move along. Complete any necessary withdrawal, explanation, or adjustment for effects that can be corrected, then tell those involved the current status. Correct wrongful penalties and stop the circulation of false information. Future interaction should respect present boundaries; nobody must pretend every relationship is restored, and past events must not be used for continued attacks.
Chapter 75: Temporary Measures
A temporary lock needs an unlocking time too
Article 771: Scope of Freedom
Apply necessary temporary restrictions to stop clear harm. As long as no clear boundary is crossed, this requires neither prior permission nor proof of some grand value to the whole group. Members may participate seriously or simply nod in passing. Obscurity, ordinariness, childishness, and spontaneous thoughts are no grounds for taking away someone's right to chat.
Article 772: Voluntary Participation
Participation in matters covered by this chapter is voluntary. When discussing Temporary Measures, do not pressure someone through group teasing, repeated persuasion, or bargaining with the closeness of a relationship into agreeing to something they do not want. You may ask once whether it is convenient, but stop when you hear a refusal. Do not supply consent on another person's behalf where they have not clearly agreed.
Article 773: Clear Boundaries
This chapter expressly opposes extending restrictions indefinitely or treating measures as a verdict in advance. Members need not present themselves as unusually strong or fragile before setting a boundary. Others may refuse and ask an action to stop. The person acting should first stop causing further effects, then explain any misunderstanding they believe exists; argument must not delay stopping.
Article 774: Hypothetical Example
For example: a short mute to prevent a pile-on is never reviewed. This situation illustrates a boundary and does not refer to any event that has already occurred in this group. Examine the original topic, subsequent additional conduct, and whether the other person expressed refusal separately. Do not overlook the affected person because everyone laughed, or treat the number of spectators as proof of the facts.
Article 775: Recommended Response
Review whether it remains necessary, adjust or lift it, and explain its status. This is a response to particular behavior, not a formula to apply mechanically without considering the facts. Ordinary misunderstandings can be clarified; clear harm must stop. Ongoing fraud, unlawful acts, or malicious harassment should be blocked immediately and the person removed. Later explanations need not delay protection of members.
Article 776: Context and Explanation
Understand Temporary Measures in this chapter in context. Exaggerated fictional scenarios, quoted text, and words addressed directly to a person may serve different purposes. Simply saying 'It's a meme' cannot end the assessment. Explain the actual meaning and original intention as clearly as possible. If the other person still does not want to receive that expression, both sides may end the related interaction.
Article 777: Information and Privacy
When explaining Temporary Measures, prioritize anonymity, summaries, and only the minimum necessary information. A problem that can be explained by describing behavior does not require full identities and every private record. Material retains privacy boundaries even within an administrative process. A complaint about someone does not make everything about that person available for unrestricted disclosure.
Article 778: Administrative Duties
When handling an issue involving Temporary Measures, administrators should explain the specific conduct and applicable boundaries, taking necessary measures based on its actual effects. Administrative status neither turns personal preferences into rules nor grants unlimited power to demand information. Disputes directly involving an administrator should be reviewed by someone without a direct conflict of interest. Resting or being offline is not, in itself, a failure of duty.
Article 779: Statements and Appeals
This chapter keeps a route open for explanations and appeals concerning Temporary Measures. Members may acknowledge mistakes or point out facts omitted from a decision. Politely doing the latter must not be punished as 'talking back.' Restrictions addressing a clear, urgent risk may be applied before review. If the grounds are insufficient or the judgment wrong, make an actual correction rather than merely say 'Be more careful next time.'
Article 780: Repair and Restoration
Once the problem involving Temporary Measures has stopped, consider how to restore ordinary conversation and the parties' normal participation. Apologies should address specific behavior and its effects. Material that needs withdrawing should actually be withdrawn, with further circulation stopped as far as possible. Do not force affected people to accept an apology, or keep humiliating someone with past events after they have corrected their conduct and the matter is closed.
Chapter 76: Levels and Proportionality of Sanctions
Exit tickets are not issued according to mood
Article 781: Scope of Freedom
This chapter recognizes the freedom to receive reminders and responses proportionate to actual conduct. Members need not perform humor, produce achievements, or satisfy anyone's aesthetic preferences to gain permission. A topic may begin with an ordinary remark and end naturally. Popularity does not determine whether expression deserves respect. Anyone uninterested may simply skip it.
Article 782: Voluntary Participation
When it comes to Levels and Proportionality of Sanctions, members may choose to watch, respond briefly, discuss seriously, or step away temporarily. None of these choices requires evidence about a person's private life. Past enthusiasm is not an obligation to remain enthusiastic now. A change in expression does not automatically mean someone is targeting a person or disrespecting the group.
Article 783: Clear Boundaries
Do not use the harshest punishment for a good-faith mistake. Assess boundaries through specific behavior, context at the time, and the wishes the other person has expressed—not merely the actor's claim about their own intentions. Jokes may be appreciated or refused. Once refusal is clear, continuing cannot be resolved simply by explaining a sense of humor.
Article 784: Hypothetical Example
Imagine this situation: a member is permanently removed for one accidental duplicate message. Address the specific new harm rather than every member participating in the topic. Stop the action currently causing effects first, then calmly check its context. Those who did not participate in the harm should not be made to confess collectively or automatically treated as guilty for watching.
Article 785: Recommended Response
Distinguish an accidental post from persistent spam and use an appropriate reminder instead. Every step should help stop the actual problem, without unrelated punishment or rituals of humiliation. Use necessary, proportionate measures in ordinary cases. Clear fraud, unlawful conduct, or malicious harassment may lead directly to removal; harm need not continue merely to reach a required warning count.
Article 786: Context and Explanation
When disagreeing about Levels and Proportionality of Sanctions, first distinguish the original words, assumptions, and your own feelings. You may say 'This is how I understand it' or 'This makes me uncomfortable.' Unchecked assumptions must not be packaged as facts 'everyone knows.' Clarification does not require immediate forgiveness, nor does it release the actor from stopping ongoing effects.
Article 787: Information and Privacy
When sharing or checking records concerning Levels and Proportionality of Sanctions, explain their purpose clearly and limit their circulation. Possessing a screenshot does not authorize unrestricted sharing. Information that has appeared in the group does not automatically become public property. Clear unrelated copies after the matter is resolved. Necessary retained records should be available only to people with actual responsibility for handling the issue, and only for that purpose.
Article 788: Administrative Duties
Administrative measures concerning Levels and Proportionality of Sanctions should restore normal participation, rather than prove that an administrator has won. When a reminder is needed, specify the behavior. When a risk needs removing, act promptly. Matters involving oneself, close associates, or personal grudges require appropriate recusal. Administrators need not be online all day, but must not use their status to retaliate against reasonable questions.
Article 789: Statements and Appeals
If a decision concerning Levels and Proportionality of Sanctions involves a misunderstanding, relevant explanations may be supplied privately, and polite questions raised about the facts, rules, and proportionality. First stop the boundary-crossing conduct you have been asked to stop, then explain the necessary context. This does not require admitting an allegation that has not been established. An administrator must not impose an additional punishment merely because someone appeals.
Article 790: Repair and Restoration
Repair under this chapter may include clarifying the facts concerning Levels and Proportionality of Sanctions, deleting content that should not be circulated, ending contact, or adjusting relevant arrangements. Repair is neither a performance of self-criticism nor a demand that both sides become close again. Affected people may keep their distance. A person who has completed the appropriate response must not be labeled indefinitely. Assess new problems through new, specific conduct.
Chapter 77: Direct Removal for Fraud, Unlawful Conduct, or Malicious Harassment
Scammers get no marketing trial period
Article 791: Scope of Freedom
Promptly preventing further damage from clear, serious harm is part of normal participation. Rules should leave room for this participation rather than turn casual conversation into an exam that only a few established friends can enter. Members need not make every remark conclusive or get a like for every contribution. A remark no one picks up is still permitted.
Article 792: Voluntary Participation
Members decide their own level of participation in matters concerning direct removal for serious violations. Every invitation should permit refusal, and every request should permit a later reply. Silence is neither a promise nor a confession others may interpret however they like. Willingness to participate today does not require the same level of involvement tomorrow.
Article 793: Clear Boundaries
This chapter restricts specific overreach, such as delaying intervention because warnings supposedly must come first. This restriction must not become a ban on the entire topic. Nor does past popularity make an expression suitable for everyone forever. Describe the conduct before discussing whether action is needed. Popularity, familiarity, and administrative status do not replace boundaries.
Article 794: Hypothetical Example
Consider this hypothetical example: fraud is continuing, yet someone demands three more chances. Even an ordinary conversation can develop beyond the scope of the original consent. Assess what actually happened, whether its effects continue, and whether it can be stopped promptly. Saying 'We all knew each other well' must not deprive affected people of a voice.
Article 795: Recommended Response
First remove the person directly and preserve necessary leads, while allowing later review. Protection and repair take priority over getting the last word. Problems resolved by stopping, withdrawing, and clarifying need not become demands for the whole group to take sides. Where the actual conduct constitutes fraud, unlawful activity, or malicious harassment, this constitution's immediate blocking and direct removal provisions apply.
Article 796: Context and Explanation
In discussions of direct removal for serious violations, brief messages may lack tone, screenshots may omit earlier context, and accounts from others may introduce inaccuracies. Good-faith questions can clarify a problem, but no one must endlessly prove they meant no harm. Where a clear boundary remains after necessary context is explained, acknowledge it and stop crossing it.
Article 797: Information and Privacy
Keep only material concerning direct removal for serious violations that is genuinely relevant to the present issue. Conceal nicknames, faces, numbers, locations, and unrelated third-party information wherever that does not prevent explaining the facts. Providing material to address a problem does not authorize members to keep sharing it, turn it into a spectacle, or make new memes from it. Recipients must respect the same boundaries.
Article 798: Administrative Duties
In matters concerning direct removal for serious violations, administrators are first ordinary members with limited responsibilities. Those handling the issue should distinguish ordinary chat opinions from administrative decisions, give clear reasons for necessary measures, and avoid collecting information beyond the issue's scope. More available authority requires greater care in explaining its purpose. Using authority to threaten, show favoritism, or disclose private information must be subject to scrutiny.
Article 799: Statements and Appeals
Parties involved in direct removal for serious violations may explain their understanding, add necessary records, and request review. Not continuing an argument after a warning prevents further effects; it does not remove the right to explain. Order cannot be maintained by banning every disagreement. Uninvolved spectators should not speak on behalf of the parties. Reviews should address specific facts and applicable boundaries.
Article 800: Repair and Restoration
Handling direct removal for serious violations must not end with merely telling everyone to move along. Complete any necessary withdrawal, explanation, or adjustment for effects that can be corrected, then tell those involved the current status. Correct wrongful penalties and stop the circulation of false information. Future interaction should respect present boundaries; nobody must pretend every relationship is restored, and past events must not be used for continued attacks.
Chapter 78: Decisions and Reasons
A verdict cannot consist only of 'Details omitted'
Article 801: Scope of Freedom
Understand the conduct, measures, and necessary reasons underlying the decision. As long as no clear boundary is crossed, this requires neither prior permission nor proof of some grand value to the whole group. Members may participate seriously or simply nod in passing. Obscurity, ordinariness, childishness, and spontaneous thoughts are no grounds for taking away someone's right to chat.
Article 802: Voluntary Participation
Participation in matters covered by this chapter is voluntary. When discussing Decisions and Reasons, do not pressure someone through group teasing, repeated persuasion, or bargaining with the closeness of a relationship into agreeing to something they do not want. You may ask once whether it is convenient, but stop when you hear a refusal. Do not supply consent on another person's behalf where they have not clearly agreed.
Article 803: Clear Boundaries
This chapter expressly opposes saying only that the administration is right without explaining anything. Members need not present themselves as unusually strong or fragile before setting a boundary. Others may refuse and ask an action to stop. The person acting should first stop causing further effects, then explain any misunderstanding they believe exists; argument must not delay stopping.
Article 804: Hypothetical Example
For example: a muted member does not know which behavior is at issue. This situation illustrates a boundary and does not refer to any event that has already occurred in this group. Examine the original topic, subsequent additional conduct, and whether the other person expressed refusal separately. Do not overlook the affected person because everyone laughed, or treat the number of spectators as proof of the facts.
Article 805: Recommended Response
Explain the necessary reasons while protecting the person's privacy. This is a response to particular behavior, not a formula to apply mechanically without considering the facts. Ordinary misunderstandings can be clarified; clear harm must stop. Ongoing fraud, unlawful acts, or malicious harassment should be blocked immediately and the person removed. Later explanations need not delay protection of members.
Article 806: Context and Explanation
Understand Decisions and Reasons in this chapter in context. Exaggerated fictional scenarios, quoted text, and words addressed directly to a person may serve different purposes. Simply saying 'It's a meme' cannot end the assessment. Explain the actual meaning and original intention as clearly as possible. If the other person still does not want to receive that expression, both sides may end the related interaction.
Article 807: Information and Privacy
When explaining Decisions and Reasons, prioritize anonymity, summaries, and only the minimum necessary information. A problem that can be explained by describing behavior does not require full identities and every private record. Material retains privacy boundaries even within an administrative process. A complaint about someone does not make everything about that person available for unrestricted disclosure.
Article 808: Administrative Duties
When handling an issue involving Decisions and Reasons, administrators should explain the specific conduct and applicable boundaries, taking necessary measures based on its actual effects. Administrative status neither turns personal preferences into rules nor grants unlimited power to demand information. Disputes directly involving an administrator should be reviewed by someone without a direct conflict of interest. Resting or being offline is not, in itself, a failure of duty.
Article 809: Statements and Appeals
This chapter keeps a route open for explanations and appeals concerning Decisions and Reasons. Members may acknowledge mistakes or point out facts omitted from a decision. Politely doing the latter must not be punished as 'talking back.' Restrictions addressing a clear, urgent risk may be applied before review. If the grounds are insufficient or the judgment wrong, make an actual correction rather than merely say 'Be more careful next time.'
Article 810: Repair and Restoration
Once the problem involving Decisions and Reasons has stopped, consider how to restore ordinary conversation and the parties' normal participation. Apologies should address specific behavior and its effects. Material that needs withdrawing should actually be withdrawn, with further circulation stopped as far as possible. Do not force affected people to accept an apology, or keep humiliating someone with past events after they have corrected their conduct and the matter is closed.
Chapter 79: Appeals and Correcting Mistakes
There is a way back from a misunderstanding
Article 811: Scope of Freedom
This chapter recognizes the freedom to request review of facts, applicable rules, and proportionality. Members need not perform humor, produce achievements, or satisfy anyone's aesthetic preferences to gain permission. A topic may begin with an ordinary remark and end naturally. Popularity does not determine whether expression deserves respect. Anyone uninterested may simply skip it.
Article 812: Voluntary Participation
When it comes to Appeals and Correcting Mistakes, members may choose to watch, respond briefly, discuss seriously, or step away temporarily. None of these choices requires evidence about a person's private life. Past enthusiasm is not an obligation to remain enthusiastic now. A change in expression does not automatically mean someone is targeting a person or disrespecting the group.
Article 813: Clear Boundaries
Do not treat a polite appeal as a new disciplinary offense. Assess boundaries through specific behavior, context at the time, and the wishes the other person has expressed—not merely the actor's claim about their own intentions. Jokes may be appreciated or refused. Once refusal is clear, continuing cannot be resolved simply by explaining a sense of humor.
Article 814: Hypothetical Example
Imagine this situation: a warned member supplies the complete record and receives another penalty for 'talking back.' Address the specific new harm rather than every member participating in the topic. Stop the action currently causing effects first, then calmly check its context. Those who did not participate in the harm should not be made to confess collectively or automatically treated as guilty for watching.
Article 815: Recommended Response
Accept the supplementary material, recheck the matter, and correct errors. Every step should help stop the actual problem, without unrelated punishment or rituals of humiliation. Use necessary, proportionate measures in ordinary cases. Clear fraud, unlawful conduct, or malicious harassment may lead directly to removal; harm need not continue merely to reach a required warning count.
Article 816: Context and Explanation
When disagreeing about Appeals and Correcting Mistakes, first distinguish the original words, assumptions, and your own feelings. You may say 'This is how I understand it' or 'This makes me uncomfortable.' Unchecked assumptions must not be packaged as facts 'everyone knows.' Clarification does not require immediate forgiveness, nor does it release the actor from stopping ongoing effects.
Article 817: Information and Privacy
When sharing or checking records concerning Appeals and Correcting Mistakes, explain their purpose clearly and limit their circulation. Possessing a screenshot does not authorize unrestricted sharing. Information that has appeared in the group does not automatically become public property. Clear unrelated copies after the matter is resolved. Necessary retained records should be available only to people with actual responsibility for handling the issue, and only for that purpose.
Article 818: Administrative Duties
Administrative measures concerning Appeals and Correcting Mistakes should restore normal participation, rather than prove that an administrator has won. When a reminder is needed, specify the behavior. When a risk needs removing, act promptly. Matters involving oneself, close associates, or personal grudges require appropriate recusal. Administrators need not be online all day, but must not use their status to retaliate against reasonable questions.
Article 819: Statements and Appeals
If a decision concerning Appeals and Correcting Mistakes involves a misunderstanding, relevant explanations may be supplied privately, and polite questions raised about the facts, rules, and proportionality. First stop the boundary-crossing conduct you have been asked to stop, then explain the necessary context. This does not require admitting an allegation that has not been established. An administrator must not impose an additional punishment merely because someone appeals.
Article 820: Repair and Restoration
Repair under this chapter may include clarifying the facts concerning Appeals and Correcting Mistakes, deleting content that should not be circulated, ending contact, or adjusting relevant arrangements. Repair is neither a performance of self-criticism nor a demand that both sides become close again. Affected people may keep their distance. A person who has completed the appropriate response must not be labeled indefinitely. Assess new problems through new, specific conduct.
Chapter 80: Restoration and Closing a Case
Return the ordinary chair when the sentence is over
Article 821: Scope of Freedom
Knowing when ordinary participation will resume after a problem stops is part of normal participation. Rules should leave room for this participation rather than turn casual conversation into an exam that only a few established friends can enter. Members need not make every remark conclusive or get a like for every contribution. A remark no one picks up is still permitted.
Article 822: Voluntary Participation
Members decide for themselves how much to participate in Restoration and Closing a Case. Every invitation should permit refusal, and every request should permit a later reply. Silence is neither a promise nor a confession others may interpret however they like. Willingness to participate today does not require the same level of involvement tomorrow.
Article 823: Clear Boundaries
This chapter restricts specific overreach, such as prolonged labeling or repeatedly reviving old cases to humiliate someone. This restriction must not become a ban on the entire topic. Nor does past popularity make an expression suitable for everyone forever. Describe the conduct before discussing whether action is needed. Popularity, familiarity, and administrative status do not replace boundaries.
Article 824: Hypothetical Example
Consider this hypothetical example: after a sanction ends, someone is still called a criminal every time they speak. Even an ordinary conversation can develop beyond the scope of the original consent. Assess what actually happened, whether its effects continue, and whether it can be stopped promptly. Saying 'We all knew each other well' must not deprive affected people of a voice.
Article 825: Recommended Response
First stop humiliation through the old case and interact on the basis of present behavior. Protection and repair take priority over getting the last word. Problems resolved by stopping, withdrawing, and clarifying need not become demands for the whole group to take sides. Where the actual conduct constitutes fraud, unlawful activity, or malicious harassment, this constitution's immediate blocking and direct removal provisions apply.
Article 826: Context and Explanation
In discussions of Restoration and Closing a Case, brief messages may lack tone, screenshots may omit earlier context, and accounts from others may introduce inaccuracies. Good-faith questions can clarify a problem, but no one must endlessly prove they meant no harm. Where a clear boundary remains after necessary context is explained, acknowledge it and stop crossing it.
Article 827: Information and Privacy
Keep only the parts of material concerning Restoration and Closing a Case that are genuinely relevant to the present issue. Conceal nicknames, faces, numbers, locations, and unrelated third-party information wherever that does not prevent explaining the facts. Providing material to address a problem does not authorize members to keep sharing it, turn it into a spectacle, or make new memes from it. Recipients must respect the same boundaries.
Article 828: Administrative Duties
In matters of Restoration and Closing a Case, administrators are first ordinary members with limited responsibilities. Those handling the issue should distinguish ordinary chat opinions from administrative decisions, give clear reasons for necessary measures, and avoid collecting information beyond the issue's scope. More available authority requires greater care in explaining its purpose. Using authority to threaten, show favoritism, or disclose private information must be subject to scrutiny.
Article 829: Statements and Appeals
Parties involved in Restoration and Closing a Case may explain their understanding, add necessary records, and request review. Not continuing an argument after a warning prevents further effects; it does not remove the right to explain. Order cannot be maintained by banning every disagreement. Uninvolved spectators should not speak on behalf of the parties. Reviews should address specific facts and applicable boundaries.
Article 830: Repair and Restoration
Handling Restoration and Closing a Case must not end with merely telling everyone to move along. Complete any necessary withdrawal, explanation, or adjustment for effects that can be corrected, then tell those involved the current status. Correct wrongful penalties and stop the circulation of false information. Future interaction should respect present boundaries; nobody must pretend every relationship is restored, and past events must not be used for continued attacks.